When I got into writing about JAV, I was never thinking about making any sort of high-level criticism or analysis. It was purely just about sharing my love and appreciation for the genre. Sharing what I like and occasionally don't like about something. JAV reviews should do the same. Inform what something is about, what might attract you to it, or what might detract from it. Simple as that.
What makes a JAV review genuinely useful in your opinion?
Answers
I want to know why the video is good, which means actually analyzing the video. What decisions did they make that you disliked and why were they wrong? Actually point it out, tell me what you would do different, and let me decide if the review came to sound decisions.